BY LEE PFEIFFER
Twilight Time has released the 1959 Fox Western "Warlock" on Blu-ray as in a limited edition of 3,000 units. To call the film a superior Western might be a bit misleading, given the fact that so many great films of this genre were released in 1950s. "Warlock" isn't a classic but it tries hard to be (perhaps a bit too hard.) What can be said is that it is a consistently interesting film with a complex script detailing the dilemmas of some very complex characters. The movie opens in the titular town, a speck on the map in the desert landscape that the official marshal for the area only rarely makes an appearance, thus forcing the townspeople to hire their own lawmen despite the fact that they lack legal status. When the movie opens, we find the town being routinely terrorized by a group of sadistic and wild cowboys led by Abe McQuown (Tom Drake). To show they are impervious to the law, they run the new marshal out of town in a particularly cruel and humiliating manner. (As with many films of this type, the townsmen are cowardly milquetoasts and even the deputy refuses to aid the marshal.) The town council decides to pay ten times the previous marshal's salary to hire Clay Blaisedell (Henry Fonda), a notorious and fearless gunman who has a reputation for restoring law and order to troubled towns. Blaisedell arrives with his constant companion, fellow gunman Tom Morgan (Anthony Quinn) and lays down the terms of his employment. In addition to his salary, Blaisedell demands complete autonomy over his methods for ridding Warlock of McQuown and his band of thugs. Additionally, he gets permission to open a gambling and prostitution sideline in the local saloon that he and Morgan will control. Out of desperation, the town council agrees.
The story focuses on a third major character in this scenario: Johnny Gannon (Richard Widmark), a disillusioned member of McQuown's gang who is becoming incensed at the senseless cruelty they practice. He stays with the gang only to keep an eye on his 19 year-old brother, Billy (Frank Gorshin), who is prone acting foolishly and impulsively. As Blaisedell and Morgan take draconian steps to confront McQuown and his men, the results become immediately apparent. However, the townspeople become leery of Blaisedell's dictatorial powers and hire Johnny Gannon to be the new marshal. Gannon has left McQuown's gang and is courageously promising to confront his former friends and ensure they leave the territory. This sets in motion competition with Blaisedell, who Gannon informs can no longer act as an unofficial arm of the law. Adding to this tension are a number of other factors that make "Warlock" play out at times like a soap opera. Blaisedell becomes engaged to local good girl Jessie Marlowe (Dolores Michaels), who is insistent that he reform his ways and adopt a respectful profession. This angers Morgan, who resents her interference. Meanwhile, Morgan is haunted the arrival in town of his ex-flame, the appropriately named prostitute Lily Dollar (Dorothy Malone), who is carrying a long-time grudge and threatens to undermine Morgan's reputation by revealing some devastating secrets about him.
There's a lot going on in "Warlock", both the town and the film, and at times the intelligent screenplay by Robert Alan Aurthur (based on the novel by Oakley Hall) seems over-stuffed with dramatic relationships and situations. At its heart, the film is about divided loyalties. Blaisedell wants to honor his promise to marry Jessie but he resents hurting Morgan in the process. Johnny Gannon is part of a gang he hesitates to leave because he feels loyal to his brother Billy and wants to act as his protector. The townspeople are grateful to Blaisedell for helping to restore peace to Warlock but they feel obliged to hire Gannon as the new lawman. I don't usually analyze films from a Freudian viewpoint because sometimes a cigar is just a cigar but one would have to willfully blind to ignore the homoerotic elements in the relationship between Blaisedell and Morgan. They are more like a married couple than old buddies. Indeed, when Blaisedell announces his engagement to Jessie, Morgan reacts like a spurned lover and has a breakdown of sorts that leads to a dramatic incident of violence. As for Blaisdell, he seems rather passive about the coming wedding, acting very much like a man who feels marriage is a mandatory part of a straight man's life, so he'd better get hitched in order to reassure himself of his masculinity. It's also worth noting that both Blaisdell and Morgan pay a lot of attention to their wardrobes and dress like dandies, which would be in line with Hollywood's perception of homosexual men in the era in which the film was made. In any event, this not-so-subtle element of the plot adds a fascinating angle to the production. The performances are uniformly excellent under the direction of Edward Dmytryk, the former blacklisted filmmaker who revived his career by naming names- which might add yet another level of Freudian analysis to a plot that centers on guilt-ridden, emotionally conflicted protagonists.
The Twilight Time region-free Blu-ray does justice to the fine cinematography of Joseph MacDonald, which makes the most of the vistas that were meant for CinemaScope. Bonus extras are limited to the original trailer, isolated score track and brief newsreel bit featuring Fonda at a charity event. There are also the usual insightful liner notes by Julie Kirgo. "Warlock" gets a bit bogged down in its own excesses (the 121 minute running time begins to make the film sag toward the end), but it is intelligent, compelling and engaging throughout. Recommended.
CLICK HERE TO ORDER