Cinema Retro continues covering films that are not currently available on home video in the U.S. or U.K.
BY BRIAN HANNAN
"Sanctuary" is an
overheated melodrama that stands as a classic example of Hollywood’s offensive
attitudes to women. Nobel prize-winning author William Faulkner could hardly
blame the movies for sensationalising his misogynistic source material since,
if anything, the movie took a softer line. The story is told primarily in flashback as headstrong southern belle
Temple Drake (Lee Remick) attempts to mitigate the death sentence passed on her
maid Nancy (Odetta). Given that such appeals are directed at Drake’s Governor
father (Howard St John), and that the maid has been condemned for murdering
Drake’s infant child, that’s a whole lot of story to swallow.
Worse is
to follow. Drake takes up with Prohibition bootlegger Candy Man (Yves Montand)
after being raped by him and thereafter appears happy to live with him in a New
Orleans brothel - the “sanctuary,” no irony intended, of the title - despite
him slapping her around. The film steers clear of turning her into the
prostitute of the original book, but pretty much sets up the notion that high
class women will fall for a low-class tough guy whose virility is demonstrated
by his brutality. In other words a “real man” rather than the dilettantes she
has previously rejected.
After the
Candy Man dies, Drake returns home and marries wealthy suitor Gowan Stevens
(Bradford Dillman) who blames himself, rightly, for Drake falling into the
clutches of the gangster in the first place. But a past threatening to engulf
her precipitates the infanticide.
Faulkner
was a Hollywood insider, adapting Sanctuary for The Story of Temple Drake
(1933) and earning high praise for his work on Bogart vehicle To Have and
Have Not (1944) and The Big Sleep (1946). The success of The
Tarnished Angels (1957) starring Rock Hudson, The Long, Hot Summer
(1958) with Paul Newman and The Sound and the Fury (1959) headlined by
Yul Brynner had sent his cachet rocketing. But all three were directed by
Americans – Douglas Sirk and Martin Ritt – who had a distinctive visual style
and an ear for what made melodrama work.
Sanctuary had been handed to British
director Tony Richardson (Look Back in Anger, 1959) and he didn’t quite
understand how to make the best of the difficult project. So while Lee Remick
manages to suggest both strength and fragility, and makes her character’s
wanton despair believable, Yves Montand is miscast and Bradford Dillman fails
to convince even though portraying a weak character. Too many of the smaller
roles appear as cliches. And it’s hard to believe the maid’s motivation in
turning murderer.
What was
acceptable steamy melodrama in the 1930s fails to click three decades on.
Faulkner’s thesis that high-falutin’ women want a man to master them and
furthermore will fall in love with their rapist seems to lack any understanding
of the female mind and will not appeal to the modern sensibility any more than
it did on release. Lee Remick is what holds the picture together, in part
because she plays so well the role of a woman embracing degradation, and
refusing – no matter how insane the idea appears – to let go of the man she
believes is the love of her life. It’s not Fifty Shades of Grey, but
it’s not that far off that kind of fantasy figure, and given the success of
that book, it’s entirely possible there is a market for what Faulkner has to
peddle.
Despite my criticisms of "Sanctuary", it still
deserves to be available on home video for retro movie lovers to form
their own opinions.
(Although "Sanctuary" is not available on home video, it can be streamed as a public domain title on YouTube.)